web tracker
WHIR.COM | BLOGS | WEB HOST NEWS | FIND WEB HOSTS | RESELLER HOSTING | MAGAZINE | WHIR TV | NEWSLETTER | rss feeds
whir blogs
WHIR BLOGS OFFERS INSIGHTFUL COMMENTARY FROM WEB HOST INDUSTRY EXPERTS    
CURRENT WEB HOSTING JOBS:  
Account CoordinatorBusiness Performance Analyst

SwapDrive vs Mozy: Innovate or Get Hammered by Innovators

I signed up for Mozy the other day. It's a remote backup service - of which you've seen plenty. BUT-

* It asks what types of files (music, for instance, or spreadsheets) you want to back up, then auto-detects new and changed files and offers block-level differential backup.
* It offers continuous backup, even on open and locked files
* It automatically reduces its own resource usage and throttles bandwidth when the computer is in use
* Your data is encrypted during transport (128-bit SSL) and while in storage (448-bit Blowfish)

In short, it's smart. And affordable. $4.95/month lets you back up as many files as you've got on one PC.

I thought of Mozy when I walked by SwapDrive's office yesterday; they're right in my neighborhood. I was a customer of theirs ages ago, but I canceled my $7.50 account when I maxed out my 100 MB limit. They wanted $50/month for upgrading me to 2GB. Can you believe it??

More importantly, while its website brags that it's the first company to offer web-based remote backup, its technology hasn't changed at all since then. I'd be surprised if they're getting very many new sign-ups.

In terms of pricing, web hosting providers have done a much better job than SwapDrive in keeping up with the times. In fact, many shared hosting plans have gone waaaay overboard, offering even more storage space and bandwidth than the average dedicated server.

But as far as technology and usability, the shared hosting product has hardly changed since I first got into the industry in 1997. And guess what? The average guy on the street still doesn't know what FTP is, much less what's in his "CGI-BIN" or what the "Server Sides" include. By the way, "Perl" looks like it's spelled funny, and how do you pronounce "MySQL"? Maybe they're waiting for the Mozy of web hosting - a more advanced service that does more for you? As a point of reference, I'd pay for Mozy even if Swapdrive were free.

So I think web hosting provider should listen to Mike over at Techdirt:

One of the most interesting things a company can do is cannibalize its own offerings. Intel famously does this on a regular basis [which is why YOUR data center hardware becomes obsolete so quickly]. If you aren't willing to do that, someone else will do it for you. One possible approach is to build a separate group, whose job is effectively to act as the competition. Let them develop the next great competitive advantage - and if it destroys your existing business, better an internal team than someone else.

Other ideas I've seen include Google's 20% time (during which engineers are free to pursue new ideas) and Yahoo's Hack Day, during which teams of employees compete to build cool things.

What I regret most about my time at EV1 was how oblivious I was to the outside world. In my mind, the business was all about today's sales inquiries and customer requests. My thinking was, we've got to focus to get through the workload! The problem is, tomorrow's customers might not need what we have to offer today. Which makes your revenue base awfully transient. So set some time aside for thinking ahead - before a new competitor (or several) comes along and does that for you.

Comments
I suspect the model will be free personal backup (2GB? that seems to be the Google-centric sweet spot for free disk) with increasing charges for SMB users, then on to a metered usage for managed storage. If you are in the storage hosting biz, you're in the storage hosting biz - personal backup, SMB desktop/server backup, managed storage - these are all just different pricing plans. Being able to "mount" managed storage (via webdav) is also a crucial piece of the pie. Has anyone seen a soup to nuts storage hosting outfit like this?
# Posted By Daniel Golding | 1/4/07 1:18 PM
Hey Dan - I just came across this New York Times article on personal backup:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/04/technology/04pog...

There's also an old TechCrunch review on many of the same players:

http://www.techcrunch.com/2006/01/31/the-online-st...

Plus I saw two S3-powered players on Amazon's site:

http://www.elephantdrive.com/
http://www.jungledisk.com (has WebDAV)

This market is almost as crowded as shared hosting - plus software features matter at least as much as the hosting infrastructure.

Mozy does have an enterprise version, for which they charge $3.95 per user plus $0.50 per GB.

On the higher end, I'm curious as to what Seagate will do with its eVault acquisition. And for server backup, I'm rooting for David Wartell's Righteous Software (http://www.r1soft.com).
# Posted By Isabel Wang | 1/4/07 5:20 PM
Hi, <a href='http://www.idrive.com/'>IDrive-E</a> offers 2GB of data backups for free. This application performs 'totally hands-free automated backups' of files and folders. There is absolutely no limit on the upload or download size for backup and restore.

IDrive-E does incremental backups that transfer only portions of file that have been modified or changed since the last backup. The user-friendly application allows you to restore large number of files with a simple drag-and-drop using the Windows Explorer like interface. All data transfer is encrypted with 128-bit Secure Socket Layer (SSL) Strong. IDrive-E also has 256-bit AES encryption on storage with an encryption password key provided by the user while installing the application.

IDrive-E has automatic schedule backup that will be continued even during machine logoff state (NT service mode). There is an option ‘Automatic Power off after scheduled backup’ with which you can automatically shut down the machine after the completion of scheduled task off-peak hours. IDrive-E retains 30 versions of backed up data and you can restore any version from these 30 versions. You can also restore latest versions of all your files or versions of files as of a specific backup set.

Of the two interfaces you can work with, the <a href='http://www.idrive.com/ide_classic.htm'>IDrive-E Classic interface</a> is a simple Microsoft Windows explore like interface used to backup and restore files and folders. You can schedule your backup for a future data and time or do immediate backups as soon as you have finished selecting the data for backups. You can also exclude files and folders from backups and delete files and folders in the IDrive-E account.

The <a href='http://www.idrive.com/ide_explorer.htm'>IDrive-E Explorer view</a> is meant for restoring files and folders and is not for backups. You can browse your IDrive-E account contents, restore files and folders with a simple drag-and-drop or copy-and-paste operation, view history of files, drag-and-drop or copy files to local drive (restore file versions) and search for files and folders backed up in your IDrive-E account.
# Posted By Zombie | 1/17/07 7:14 AM
The 'zombie' post is copy written by the IDrive-E folks that you can find all over the net.

I have created screencasts on both Mozy and IDrive-E, which positions itself as a direct competitor to Mozy. You can see the screencasts here:

http://mainstream-guides.com/Mozy
http://mainstream-guides.com/IDrive-E

The surface differences are that Mozy is both Mac and Windows, whereas IDrive-E is Windows-only, and IDrive-E will archive files that you remove from your hard drive, whereas Mozy only guarantees keeping files around for 30-days after you delete them locally.

As you'll see, however, I think there are other reasons to prefer Mozy...
# Posted By eisenworks | 7/25/07 3:34 PM
A downside to Mozy is their poor support. I tried to get help to make Mozy work on my PC for 4 months, and all they said was try the latest version.
I was happy to find out about the poor support before I really needed their help.

Also idrive give freephone support in the US
# Posted By 2003amir | 9/9/07 5:24 AM
Interesting... For evaluation purposes, I have been running both IDrive-E and Mozy on my machine for a couple of months, now. My experience has been just the opposite:

- IDrive-E keeps backing up things I never asked it to back up, and then telling me I have gone over the limit, and asks me to convert to the paid version. The support folks tell me 'just download the latest version.' Recently, the icon blinks at me about once a week and tells me to download another version. Stuff shows up on the backup list, and I have no idea how it got there.
- Mozy just works. I have asked their support staff questions about Mozy's operation, and all have been responded to. I understand much better how to get it to backup what I want it to backup.

The main thing going for IDrive-E is that you can archive files with it, and then delete them from your hard drive. If you do this on Mozy, they also delete those files, after a period of time. That makes the two services functionally different.

A more important difference -- particularly if you have large files (e.g. videos) to back up, is that IDrive-E's "unlimited" version, if you read the fine print, is actually limited to 150 mb. Mozy's, which costs the same $4.95/month, is really unlimited. They deal with this question straightforwardly in their FAQ. This, in my mind, is a much bigger functional difference.

Oh, yeah... I keep forgetting this: Mozy works for Mac users. IDrive-E does not.
# Posted By eisenworks | 9/9/07 11:03 AM
Oops! Big correction: IDrive-E's "unlimited" version is limited to 150 gigabytes -- not 150 megabytes. Now I'll get that second cup of coffee...
# Posted By eisenworks | 9/9/07 11:10 AM
I finally found a guide to online backup!
It’s got lots of useful info on the most popular services!
It’s a great way to protect and share computer files.
I found it on wikipedia but I put it online at:
<a href="http://memopal.clickmeter.com/495916.html">mini guide to online backup</a>
# Posted By elys | 6/20/08 9:04 AM
 
 

Find Web Hosts | Reseller Hosting | Personal Web Hosting | Small Business Web Hosting | Dedicated Servers | Managed Hosting | Adult Web Hosting
Reseller Hosting | Web Hosting Automation | Wholesale Domain Names | Private Label Web Hosting | Web Host Advertising Agencies | Host Services


About WHIR | Online Advertising | Print Advertising | Print Subscription | Email Newsletters | RSS Feeds
 
Submit News | Privacy Policy | Buy Reprints
Web Host Industry Review, Inc. is not responsible for the content of comment submitted by our users.

  © Copyright Web Host Industry Review, Inc.