As I sat around pondering the politics of the day, I thought to myself that it all seems ridiculous. I can’t decide what is worse – the politicians arguing over the debt ceiling debate or how poorly the topic is understood by most people in America. I’m not going to argue whether or not it is wise to raise the debt ceiling, or what strings need to be attached to the increase. It has to be done. That is fact, can’t be argued, and all the media and political nonsense attached to the “debate” is just that – nonsense.
Last night I was discussing it with someone and she asked me why the country needed more debt. To her, like many Americans, more debt seemed to be bad. If we already have too much debt, than adding more must be a bad thing, right? Well, I explained, the answer is not nearly that simple. In fact, debt is not intrinsically bad. And businesses acquiring debt are not the same as consumers irresponsibly running up their credit cards as Republicans have inappropriately framed it. Our government is a business, and government debt is business debt. You can argue the finer points of the whole “government is a business” statement, and whether or not the government is a good or efficient business, but as a broad approximation that is really the best way to describe it. The government, as a business, provides useful and valuable services that we can’t live without. Again, some of them may be debatable (thank you NPR), but in general this statement is true. And our country is growing, albeit slowly an unevenly. Here is where debt comes in. Some level of debt, for most healthy, growing businesses is acceptable and necessary. Let’s look at this from a web hosting perspective. XYZHost sells dedicated servers to small businesses. To do this, they need to provide a datacenter, server hardware, software, and tech support among other things. While it would be ideal if they could collect money from customers in advance and then go out and buy what they need to provide service, it just doesn’t work that way. You need capital to acquire equipment, rent space, and hire people in advance of actually signing up your first customers. And as you grow, the same rules apply. You can’t handle rapidly growing demand unless you utilize debt or your business is very profitable with significant cash flow. Just because you need debt to grow, doesn’t mean your model is broken or that your business is not successful. Some business types, particularly technology related business that require infrastructure, need more capital than others. Government is also a capital-intensive business. So, you’re hosting business is growing and you need capital to expand.
What are your options? Well, you can borrow money, either from a bank, a leasing company, or even a factoring company that will buy your receivables. They vary in cost and effectiveness, but they all get cash in your coffers to fund your growth. Your business can have debt AND be profitable – these are not mutually exclusive as many people believe them to be. Debt can finance capital equipment, which depreciates over its lifecycle rather than being expensed at the time of purchase. Debt allows you to buy things up front that you need to do business, but in many cases their cost is essentially amortized over their useful life. Sorry for business and econ 101 here, but it blows my mind how few people seem to really grasp these concepts.
What else can you do? Another option to fund your growth is to raise prices for existing customers. If you’re the government, this is raising taxes. As I mentioned in a previous post, this can be tolerated to a limited extent, but is generally unwise especially in a tough economic climate. When you raise rates, these increases generally go right to the bottom line because you are charging more money for the same services. But if it were that easy, everyone would do it. If you’re a company, and you get too aggressive with the increases, your customers’ businesses will suffer and they may look elsewhere for services. The government has a more captive customer base, but in a global economy it is naïve to think that taxpayers, especially corporate taxpayers, don’t have options. Not only do unfavorable tax rates crimp consumers, one of the engines of our economy, but they also encourage companies to focus business activities in countries that offer more favorable taxation policies.
So, in summary, understand that the debt ceiling debate has nothing to do with the debt ceiling. Our country can’t continue to do business without the ability to raise more debt. You can argue that we need to pay down some of our debt in the long term, reduce spending, and increase revenue, but none of those things really pertain to whether we need to auction more government bonds or start prioritizing payments on August 2nd. This is simply blackmail and gamesmanship, using something important that needs to be done as a means to a political end. Whether you are Republican or Democrat, conservative or liberal, you shouldn’t get sucked into this, nor should anyone tolerate or support this behavior from our elected officials. And maybe instead of blaming them for their awful and childish behavior, we should blame ourselves for electing them.