Subscribe for daily, weekly or monthly web hosting news updates by email!

WINSTREAM ACQUISITION WAS AN OIBDA DEAL

By Tom Millitzer on November 13, 2009

Possibly you have read one of my dissertations regarding EBITDA – including the various forms of prounciation.  As a refresher you will also note that I prefer the term “Cash before DAIT” because it places the emphasis on “CASH” – which in the end is the purpose of one of your Web Hosting acquistition exercises. That is the cash on hand to pay for stuff after the transaction, not including operating costs.

In looking at your friend Cash Before DAIT, the buyer looks at how much cash is available, typically for debt service and capital expenditures, extra cash is always suggested. In otherwords, how you are going to pay for your hosting acquisition.

Reviewing this weeks  $333 million Windstream acquisition of D&E Communications I noticed the deal was stated in OIBDA, thanks I said. I don’t toss this around often, OK never do, but I like it.

Lets look why:

OIBDA “Operating Income Before Depreciation And Amortization” does not include non-operating income. For your general calculation you will use---

 OIBDA = Operating Income+Depreciation+Amoritization+Interest

For a great example I suggust you review the clickable Windstream graphic.

You will note that the calculation is started with GAAP net operating income vs. EBITDA which is stated with GAAP net income.

Now you can see why I like it (Even though they left off the "T", who pays taxes anyway?), I believe you will agree that it is a better representation of the deal especially for “RECCURING CASH FLOW” based business like Web Hosting, which is why Windstream used it in it's presentation. And, it is one of those things in life I was actually doing in my presentations, but no one told me.

I know you want the easy understandable version, so do I.  So accountants please do not criticize or generally get in the way, this is an operational and acquisition discussion. Technically this stuff should occur near the bottom of the Operating Statement (P&L).

Between the “O” line and the “E” line there are items that you may want to exclude or include in my (Tom’s) “CASH” calculation.

You note that hidden in the CASH other things may be considered (hence OBIDA), they should be between the O and the E lines (unless different terms are used) or if not hidden elsewhere, usually you are looking for items that are not recurring every year.

Here are some suggestions if you were initially buying a Company that previously had $10 million in “CASH”.

    •    Your are buying a Hosting Company but it sold off $1m of old servers, don’t count that.

    •    You are buying a Web Hosting Company that sold off a “shared hosting” division and profited $1m from the sale, don’t count that either (and you will have many other calculations to look at).

Now you have $9 million of "CASH" that you can use.

In other words you are looking at things you cannot anticipate ever happening again or does not apply. Personally I think we should all just term this as "Tom's CASH" or the CASH you can count on.

I will caution you however, not all these things are in practice stated near the bottom of the operating statement. They should but they don’t. For example you may find those server sales are hidden in the revenues lines, way at the top and not between the “O and E”. Conversely you may find “restructuring expenses” (management screw-ups), hidden somewhere in the expenses above that “O” line, buts that’s a different story.

For practical purposes, I suggest that if your company is nearing $5 million in revenues you considered audited financial statement that should clear up your possible GAAP faux pas.

The bottom line.  Do your due-diligence, tear apart the operating statements so they make sense to your and your business. I know you would do that anyway. Make up your own version of "Tom's CASH"

In conclusion:

For us valuation buffs Windstar acquired D&E for exactly 5X OBIDA

Suggested OBIDA pronunciations:

“OOO BID A” With a decidely German accent twist.

“O BGIDA” Like Bogotá Columbia on October 31st.

More about Tom: NCC - the Hosting Business Broker   Twitter - TomNCC

 E-Mail Tom Direct

 

RSS Tom Millitzer provides merger and acquisition services to Internet service firms including Web Hosting, Data Centers and similar sectors. In 1994 he founded and is President of  NCC International /New Commerce Communications, Inc. He has been involved in almost 300 mergers and acquisitions... (Read full bio)

OLDER: Photos from PubCon 2009 | NEWER: New Video on WHIR tv - Interview with John Zanni of Microsoft

Comment anonymously or log into your WHIR account

Logging in allows enhanced commenting features (such as external linking) in news, features, blogs and more.

User:

Pass:

(reset password)

Don't have an account yet? Register now!


 

Read Back Issues of WHIR Magazine

October 2009 - Web Hosting's All Star Team
This has been, for us, one of the most interesting, exciting and challenging build-ups to an issue of the magazine yet, Web Hosting's All Star Team. The balloting process was our first experiment with a kind of user participation we're planning to do a lot more with in the months to come. We had thousands of ballots submitted, with hundreds of write-in suggestions and a demonstration of user engagement that has us feeling super positive about the project.
About This Issue | Read Digital Edition

July 2009 - What am I Worth?
One of the interesting luxuries of working on a project like the printed WHIR magazine is that it allows us to play with things like our point of view from one issue to the next. In recent months we've been giving added attention to the kind of practical and applicable advice aimed at smaller hosts and resellers. This issue carries on with that point of view, asking, in our cover story, "what am I worth?" It's a complicated question without a clear-cut answer.
About This Issue | Read Digital Edition

May 2009 - The Blueprint for a Small Web Host
I was a little surprised by how difficult it became to see this idea through. We set out to assemble a blueprint for a small hosting business, but butted up pretty quickly against the general impossibility of covering all the territory that was out there to be covered. The basic constraints of a printed magazine, and the less-than-infinite amount of time we had available forced us to face the fact that we could never produce an exhaustive guide to starting a hosting company.
About This Issue | Read Digital Edition

Read more WHIR Magazine back issues